Friday, October 16, 2009

How old are you?

George walks into my office. I ask him his age.

"I'm 21 years old," he declares.

Yet I look at George. He's got gray thinning hair, his posture is slumped forward rather than erect, the flesh on his upper arms hangs loosely, he's got wrinkles on his hands and face, brown spots on the back of his hands and arms. He looks more like 70 years old to me. "I don't think you're 21 years old. I think you're 70."

"Prove it," he says.

Okay. What now? Minus any formal identification like a driver's license, how do I prove that George is really 70-something and not 20-something? Not an easy thing, when you think about it. If George were a tree, I'd cut him down and count his rings. Is there such a phenomenon in humans?

This is actually a fascinating area of research, looking for reliable biomarkers of aging.

Among the most quantitative markers of aging is telomere length. Telomeres were once dismissed as nonsense sequences in DNA. However, more recent thought among geneticists is that telomeres shorten with aging and provide the body's cells a timeline of aging. This way, George's cells act like they are 70, not 13, and don't start producing gobs of growth hormone and testosterone in preparation for puberty.

What can slow or stall the shortening of telomere length? There are two I'm aware of:

1) Caloric deprivation--i.e., taking in fewer calories. This was among the theories explored by Dr. Roy Walford during his Biosphere2 experience, based on his work in mice that showed that caloric deprivation nearly doubled lifespan.

2) Vitamin D--Richards et al (2007) found that, the higher the vitamin D, the longer the telomere length. The highest vitamin D levels conferred a 5-year effective difference in telomere length.

So, if I could look inside George's cells and count his telomeres, I could judge with confidence whether he was 21 or 70. Or, he could take vitamin D sufficient to increase blood levels to a healthy range and be more like 65.

17 comments:

Ellen said...

"gobs"


Hahaha... I can so tell you are from Milwaukee. That is such a Wisconsin expression. :D

Ellen said...
This post has been removed by the author.
LeonRover said...

Another take on the Greek philosophical question: what is time? Even tho' they could count days and years, their answer was: "time is the measure of change". But perhaps that should be reversed to: "change is the measure of time".

Doc, it seems to me the burden of proof was on the guy. You simply say: you only left high school three years ago? Gosh, there are no reports that any male has undergone the developmental changes I can see, in such a short time!
Another point, the number of telomeres at the end of cells has to be calibrated against other measures, such as the sun going round the earth. All any particular individual has to claim is: my telomeres are lost 10 times faster than any one else's, now YOU prove otherwise.

Y'all have a good day, now.

Anonymous said...

"If George were a tree, I'd cut him down and count his rings"
Too funny, Dr Davis.

George's telomere's....reduced to T-stumps.

Ellie

Telephone Triage said...

Lovely blog...it is scary the way we are being attacked by the diseases at very early ages also.

Tim said...

Al Sears says that high homocystein levels shortens telemores three times faster.

Peter said...

I take vitamin D and I want to live longer. I believe it will help because you said so,and I believe everything you say, including when you say you're not sure.

Peter said...

Regarding "gobs", this is a popular expression in Oregon, too, and I'm not sure how you tell where an expression originated.

Matthew said...

Dr. Davis,

Have you heard about ELC (earlobe crease) as a possible key sign of aging? It seems that tons of studies show a very strong positive connection between younger people with an earlobe crease and CVD. What do you think?

Bad_CRC said...

3) The Ornish diet.

http://www.thelancet.com/journals/lanonc/article/PIIS1470-2045(08)70234-1/fulltext

David Throop said...

Doc Davis,

Last week, the U.S. Preventive Services Task Force came out with a review and with recommendations about using emerging risk factors for predicting and managing heart disease. I think there's a lot in there that you'll agree with. But they were negative about calcium scoring.

Sandy Swarz, whose scholarship is pretty sharp, gives a summary.

I'd really like to see your response to all this.

Michelle said...

It is scary how many young people are getting elderly diseases. I know someone who died of a massive MI at the age of 26. I am also proof of that. I have CAD, hypothyriodism, Low Vitamin D, Low B12, gastritis, and valve disease and I am only 35. I am looking forward to being able to reverse some of these diseases naturally.

Michelle

Dr. William Davis said...

Hi, Matthew--

I believe there's some evidence that ear lobe creases are associated with increased coronary risk, but I don't know of any data relating them in younger people specifically.

I have one myself, and it's been there for as long as I can remember and does indeed correlate with my family's aggressive heart disease pattern.

Dr. William Davis said...

Hi, G--

As always, you are full of unique observations.


Hi, Ellen--

Perhaps I should have said "oodles."

rezzrovv said...

Dr. Davis,

See David Throop's comment above. I actually came looking to see if you might have commented on this yet. Curious your take.

Scott Pierce

Anonymous said...

Hi Dr. Davis,

Have you observed a correlation between earlobe creases and coronary calcification among your patients?

Thanks,

David

Stan (Heretic) said...

Hi Dr. B G,

Interesting. Magnesium deficiency vs telomeres length could also be explained as a secondary effect caused by the excessive metabolism of carbohydrates as the primary factor. High magnesium intake is required for glucose metabolism, see for example Implications of oxidative stress in high sucrose low magnesium diet fed rats

Similar situation may exist with glutathione, high glutatione may be a secondary marker for a diet high in dairy and (thus automatically) lower in carbohydrates. This paper you linked Maternal diet influences DNA damage, aortic telomere length, oxidative stress, and antioxidant defense capacity in rats seems to be pointing to a high carb diet as one of the factors that may cause accelerated growth of low birth weight babies (the paper discusses human studies as well), which then is correlated with higher CVD risk, shorter telomeres and worsens other markers (bones abnormality etc).

In contrast to this, high fat low carb nutrition seems to slow down babies and infants growth and slows the onset of puberty, which according to the logic presented by the papers discussed above, ought to reduce oxidative stress, slow down the shortnening of telomeres and reduce the CVD risk later in life.
Regards,
Stan