Sunday, January 11, 2009

Niacin scams

In the Track Your Plaque program, we often resort to niacin (vitamin B3 or nicotinic acid) to:

--Raise HDL cholesterol
--Reduce the proportion of small LDL particles
--Shift HDL towards the healthy larger fraction (HDL2b or "large")
--Reduce lipoprotein(a), the most aggressive risk factor known


But niacin comes with a crazy "hot flush," a warm, prickly feeling that usually envelops the upper chest, neck and face that is, without a doubt, annoying. Around 1 in 20 people simply cannot tolerate any amount of niacin >100 mg, while others have no problem even into the 3000 mg per day or more range. (Tolerance to niacin is genetically determined, governed by the rapidity of metabolism to the niacin metabolite, nicotinuric acid.)

The niacin flush has spawned an entire panel of niacin-like scams, agents that sound like niacin or may even contain niacin, but exert no beneficial effect whatsoever:

Flush-free niacin--I have previously posted on this useless but ubiquitous preparation that often costs several times more than conventional niacin. Flush-free niacin, or inositol hexaniacinate, does indeed contain niacin, but it is not released in the human body. You simply pass it out down the toilet, where this preparation belongs in the first place.

Nicotinamide--Also called niacinamide. While the nicotinamide/niacinamide forms of vitamin B3 can be used to treat B3 deficiency ("pellagra"), they do not reproduce the lipid and lipoprotein effects of niacin. For our purposes, they are useless.

Niacin-containing heart-healthy supplements--These are the multi-supplements that contain a little of everything that might be beneficial for the heart, but none at a dose that provides genuine benefit. Don't throw your money away.


There's also a prescription niacin, Niaspan, that costs 20-fold more than the best over-the-counter preparation, Sloniacin. Niaspan has yielded hundreds of millions of dollars for the pharmaceutical industry. Your money, in my view, is far better spent on Sloniacin (around $12-14 per bottle of 100 tablets of 500 mg).

For more on niacin, here's an article I wrote for the Life Extension Magazine people a while back: Using Niacin to Improve Cardiovascular Health.

9 comments:

auntulna said...

I've been taking Slo-niacin for more than six months, and about three times it must have broken down too fast. That is an intense hot pins and needles rush! Anyone else had that happen?

Grandma S. said...

Dr. Davis,
I do appreciate your blog and the information you provide. I am switching to SloNiacin!

stern said...

it appears to me that the only final decisive enemy for the heart is the LA sort LDL,all other are the indicators that your body inclines forward to get that enemy .all other encompassess high tryglicerides ,high ldl,low small hdl,c reactive proyien ,am i wright ?

Anonymous said...

Niamax is also a slow release niacin.

Is Niamax acceptable or does it also fall into the scam group?

Anonymous said...

Please comment on a niacin product I have been using for years by Endurance Products,a sustained form of nicotinic acid that causes no flush (1000 mg daily) plus their regular version of immediate release (250 mg daily). Thanks...

martha said...

Hi—
My name is Martha and I am a writer working on a story about niacin for Better Homes & Gardens' Heart-Healthy Living magazine. I hope to interview Dr. Davis but also wanted to talk to people who are taking niacin for my story. If you are interested, please email me at marthajmiller@hotmail.com. My deadline is Feb. 16. Thanks
-martha miller

IggyDalrymple said...

My VA doc has been prodding me for years to take statins for my bad LDL/HDL ratio. I finally took Dr Davis' advice and starting taking niacin and it worked. My doc is now happy.

SES said...

There are so many people commenting on the side effects of statins I wonder if there are side effects to something like Niaspan. Hot flashes are not what I am talking about.

Mary P said...

I was talking to a dietitian friend about your strong feelings about no-flush niacin. I'm confused because she pointed me towards a recent European Food Standards Agency report that states that inositol hexanicotinate is bioavailable to humans and a source of niacin (they say, on average, 70% of an oral dose is absorbed into the blood stream).